Tuesday, May 28, 2013

Popularity, Crabs, and Condescension



Can we talk about something for a minute? Seriously, I need to get this off my chest.

Black people are forever saying that racism is an American institution. “It’s as American as apple pie and ‘red, white, & blue’ and all that”…sure it is. No argument there. However, we have our own problem that is equally damaging.



It’s the problem of black condescension.

If you mixed the ‘crab in a barrel’ mentality with the power of popular opinion, you’d have this idea of black condescension.

“How does the crab thing fit”…glad you asked. We tend to place those whose opinions, ideas, and actions fall outside of popular opinion – or stereotype – below us in the barrel. We make them outcasts and say they’re not “black enough” and so on. It’s just awful that we (and yes, I mean we: I’m guilty of this too) place this unnecessary burden on ourselves and each other.

Alright, enough of that. Let’s get to some examples. Note: most, if not all, of these will denote the same line of division between black people.

College: funny thing about this one is that it actually goes both ways. People who went to HBCUs often challenge the blackness of those who went to PWIs, and people who went to PWIs often challenge the class (and sometimes intelligence) of those who went to HBCUs. Going to a PWI doesn’t make you bougie and going to an HBCU doesn’t make you ghetto.

Music: Some people listen to Lupe. Some people listen to Gucci. Usually, people in the former group are horribly condescending toward people in the latter group. They’ll swear their way is the right way and that the ills of the black community would be cured if rappers like Gucci and Chief Keef fell off the face of the earth. You know who else thinks their way is the right way, all others be cursed? Exactly.

Tyler Perry: TP divides black people as much as any one person I can think of. He obviously doesn’t have this intent, but we all know that his work has been a lightning rod in the black community for years. The man makes film and theater designed to entertain and uplift but people hate him for it. People who talk about his craftsmanship are fine. People who say he perpetuates stereotypes and attack him as a person: have the empty stadium. Please.

Geography: yeah, this one here…northerners love to say that southerners are country, backwards, unintelligent, and so on. I’m going to fight the urge to say some things I could say (going negative would undermine the entire post) and point out that things are pretty nice down here. Our state leaders are jacked up politically, but we have things that cancel them out.

---

For people who were mad at previous exclusionary tactics throughout history, we’ve done a lot to copy them. If we don’t find a way to stop that, there’s a good chance that we will stop our collective progress.

1 comment:

  1. "The easiest way to get one man to hate another is to tell him he is better than the other man." - I forget the source.

    ReplyDelete